Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (2024)

by RetroRuth | Mar 12, 2014 | Beef, Holiday, Main Dishes, St. Patrick's Day | 23 comments

St. Patrick’s Day is almost here! And what better way to celebrate then with a corned beef gelatin mold!

This is Hearty Corned Beef Salad.

And yes, I’m serious.

Hearty Corned Beef Salad

Author: Betty Crocker Step by Step Recipes, 1975

Ingredients

  • 1 cup boiling water
  • 1 pkg (3 oz) lemon flavored gelatin
  • 2 T vinegar
  • 1 can (12 oz) corned beef
  • 2 medium stalks celery, chopped (about 1 cup)
  • 1 medium green pepper, chopped (about 1 cup)
  • 1 small onion, chopped (about 1/4 cup)
  • 3 hard-cooked eggs, chopped
  • 1 cup mayo or salad dressing
  • 2 tsp horseradish
  • 1/2 tsp salt
  • salad greens

Instructions

  1. Pour boiling water on gelatin in large bowl; stir until gelatin is dissolved. Stir in vinegar and refrigerate until slightly thickened, about an hour
  2. Break up corned beef with a fork. Stir corned beef and remaining ingredients (except salad greens) into gelatin mixture.
  3. Pour mixture into 6 1/2 cup gelatin mold. Refrigerate until set, about 2 hours. Unmold on salad greens. Salad can be stored up to 48 hours.

When you are making crazy stuff like this, you have to take some joy in the small, non-insane details. Every time I use my vintage metal egg slicer, it makes me happy. No modern egg slicers are even half as good as this one!

To bad this poor sliced egg is going to end up in a corned beef gelatin mold.

Yep. This seems about right.

Of course, this thing smelled pretty terrible. But there was worse to come.

This is where this recipe gets a little crazy. It molded just fine and unmolded fine as well, but when I went to cut this thing I got a horrible surprise.

It made this sucking sound. This horrible, wet sucking sound, like when you pull the skin off of half frozen chicken. Or when you are cutting raw meat off the bone. It was incredibly creepy. I could feel the little hairs on the back of my neck standing up every time I did it.

So, of course, I kept doing it.

Tom came in the room just as I was cutting the mold into it’s last slice.

“Holy crap, is that coming from that corned beef thing?”

“Yes.”

“That’s a frickin’ creepy sound.”

“I know!”

“It sounds like someone eating someone else. It should be on The Walking Dead.”

“Okay, that’s gross.”

“No, what’s gross is that sound.”

“Well, guess what? Now you get to eat it.”

“Great.” He took his slice and sat down, and cut a piece off with his fork. “Ugh. It’s making that sound again.”

“How horrible is it?”

“I love it.”

“Shut up! Seriously?”

“Yes.”

“You know, maybe you have been eating too many gelatins.”

“Or drinking too many drinks. There might be lots of reasons.”

The Verdict: Good

From Tom’s Tasting Notes –

Surprisingly sweet yet delicious. Raw onions are a bit overpowering. A bit like a sweet (German) potato salad. If there were fewer onions, I could eat a lot of this…or maybe it’s the grasshoppers talking.

From Ruth’s Tasting Notes –

Actually not that bad, but way too sweet for me. I don’t know who the…person is who decided that sweet lemon gelatin could be made savory by adding vinegar to it, but it DOESN’T WORK. It might actually have beendelicious if the gelatin had been plain with just some lemon juice like this potato salad gelatin. Also, I picked out all the onions. Onions in sweet gelatin are an abomination. I’m not kidding.

  1. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (10)

    Lassieon March 12, 2014 at 11:28 am

    I was gonna say….plain gelatin, not lemon, and I would eat this thing! can’t account for the creepy sound, but food sometimes makes noises.

  2. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (11)

    Michellleon March 12, 2014 at 11:33 am

    I just about busted out laughing..hysterical!

  3. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (12)

    Poppyon March 12, 2014 at 12:09 pm

    Why didn’t they specify lime gelatin so it would be greener? We’ve already established that taste is apparently not the primary concern anyway…

  4. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (13)

    CATon March 12, 2014 at 12:13 pm

    I’m not a huge canned meat fan. Looking at your picture, I think you could substitute dog food, and it wouldn’t even matter!!! You are SO brave to try these recipes.

  5. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (14)

    Miaon March 12, 2014 at 4:26 pm

    This looks like what my dog hacked up on my bed the other day…

  6. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (15)

    Tipsykiton March 12, 2014 at 9:12 pm

    I was thinking the same thing about the gelatin! And that corned beef looks an awful lot like the contents of a can of cat food. And the picture of the whole mess being put into the mold made me gag a little bit, ugh.

  7. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (16)

    Susanon March 12, 2014 at 10:45 pm

    Cat – My thoughts EXACTLY.

    And how in heaven’s name did they ever convince their kids to eat this back in the 70s? (I was 25 at that time – I wouldn’t have TOUCHED this – it was disgusting even back then.)

  8. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (17)

    karenliseon March 13, 2014 at 1:08 pm

    Of all the recipes…………. I could not eat that one.

  9. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (18)

    celiaon March 13, 2014 at 9:43 pm

    Oh DAYUM. Anyhow we made glorious corned beef and roasted sprouts and new potatoes last week and used the leftovers in SOS. It was great. I would be on board(ish) for this with plain gelatin. Tom has jumped the shark.

    GUUURL it is almost lamb cake time and my four year old is full on ready. I am less ready and freaked out to bake one. And then decorate it? That seems like a lot of cake for four people. It’s happening though.

  10. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (19)

    Denita Ruhnowon March 14, 2014 at 4:41 pm

    Maybe sub plain gelatin for the lemon, and minced cooked corned beef instead of the canned yuck? As for the sound…yeah, off-putting. But then, I get a mite queasy just hearing macaroni and cheese being stirred up. (C’mon, tell me I’m not the only one that gets squicked out by that wet smacky-crackly sound? Like millions of tiny leech mouths smacking hungrily. Eeeeeugh.)

  11. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (20)

    Carolon March 16, 2014 at 10:41 am

    i really am so glad that you actually give these old recipes a real shot instead of just making fun of them. honestly if someone set any of these old gelatin mold salads down in front of me i’d at least try it. and the fact that one or both of you actually like some of them is so fab! thanks so much for doing this – i really love your posts!

  12. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (21)

    Deeon March 20, 2014 at 5:37 pm

    I would almost try this just to hear the horrible sucking noise as you described it. Yes, I am that person. I would gleefully slice this up, while laughing maniacally. I’m not sure I would eat it though.

  13. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (22)

    Yinzerellaon March 17, 2016 at 10:09 am

    What is the pretty co*cktail in the picture?

  14. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (23)

    Dave Fon March 17, 2016 at 4:41 pm

    I always knew my mom forgot to buy boloney when, in high school, in the 60s, my lunch contained canned corn beef sandwiches. Actually was better than cheese sandwiches with ketchup.

  15. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (24)

    Cara Caraon March 20, 2016 at 4:23 am

    It appears to be a grasshopper

  16. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (26)

    T.C.on September 10, 2016 at 9:11 am

    Just read the lead-in article today on Yahoo! Then came over here for the recipe.

    Hate to tell you kids, but I’ve eaten stuff very much like this. My Mom and Dad were married during the depression. A lot of things in my house growing up were transferred from that time.

    I learned a lot about making do with what you have and I’ve always put those skills to work for me.

    Ask yourselves this – what would you do if you suddenly didn’t have all the things you have today? I hope you would all get creative to survive.

    This recipe isn’t that awful – especially when your tummy is grumbling!

  17. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (27)

    BARB PIETRANGELOon September 10, 2016 at 10:45 am

    I happened to have a can of corned beef in my pantry to make a reuben casserole-so I am going to give this a try……results to be advised!!!! My mom made me corned beef salad sandwiches that had green tomato relish mixed with salad dressing and she chopped the corned beef really finely. Pretty tasty.

  18. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (28)

    RetroRuthon September 10, 2016 at 11:04 am

    Go for it! 🙂 I would advise using unflavored gelatin and leaving out at least half of the onions. We’ve made this several times and it’s actually pretty good that way.

  19. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (29)

    RetroRuthon September 10, 2016 at 11:06 am

    This is a 1970’s version of a depression recipe, so I’m sure that the original recipe was much better. We ended up liking it, and it is even better if you use unflavored gelatin and halve the onions. Probably cheaper as well! 🙂

  20. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (30)

    Mark Brozakon September 10, 2016 at 12:22 pm

    This sounds interesting and I plan to try it, I think I have everything except the gelatin and “½ tsp sald”. Is that supposed to be “½ tsp salt”?

    This was “Posted on Mar 12 2014”, I’m surprised the culinary desk jockies that have commented in the past 2 years haven’t asked. I am going to make it so I’m asking to make sure.

  21. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (31)

    Paton September 10, 2016 at 1:45 pm

    Simple ingredients and a good flavor. Very easy to prepare, too.
    It is a nutritious dish. We used non-canned corned beef from the meat counter.
    We liked it.

  22. Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (32)

    RetroRuthon September 10, 2016 at 1:55 pm

    Yup, it’s salt! Sorry about that, I’ve fixed it. 🙂

Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu (2024)

FAQs

Hearty Corned Beef Salad – A Mid-Century St. Patrick’s Day Recipe Test - Mid-Century Menu? ›

» Food and Drink

Traditional Irish foods like corned beef and cabbage, Boxty, and Irish soda bread, are often served on Saint Patrick's Day. Drinking green beer or Guinness on St. Patrick's Day is also a popular tradition. People drink a lot of Guinness on this holiday!

What do the Irish eat with corned beef? ›

» Food and Drink

Traditional Irish foods like corned beef and cabbage, Boxty, and Irish soda bread, are often served on Saint Patrick's Day. Drinking green beer or Guinness on St. Patrick's Day is also a popular tradition. People drink a lot of Guinness on this holiday!

Why do the Irish eat corned beef on St. Patrick's Day? ›

Their best option for a lower-cost meat was, you guessed it: corned beef. What was once a luxury item became a food that was now inexpensive and readily available. So it was the Irish-American consumption of corned beef that initiated its association with Ireland and the holiday of St. Patrick's Day.

What is the superstition about corned beef and cabbage? ›

Many with Irish heritage prepare Corned beef and cabbage dinner on New Year's day. It is associated with the fortune you should hope for in the coming year. Beef or pork is the meat of choice because unlike chickens these animals do not scratch in the dirt for their food.

Is corned beef and cabbage not Irish? ›

But some Irish Americans might be surprised by another entry on that list of suspect foods: corned beef and cabbage. Experts say the meal originated on American soil in the late 19th century as Irish immigrants substituted corned beef for bacon, which was meat of choice in the homeland.

What do Irish people eat on St. Paddy's Day? ›

Patrick's Day party, including soda bread and a seriously tasty trifle to whip up for dessert.
  • Bacon and Cabbage. ...
  • Irish Soda Bread. ...
  • Irish Stew. ...
  • Irish Coffe. ...
  • Corned Beef and Cabbage. ...
  • Colcannon.

What do the Irish eat on St. Paddy's Day? ›

Spring lamb comes into season around St. Patrick's Day, and roasts, such as a leg of lamb with rosemary, are popular. Pies are, too, such as fish pies (made with cod or haddock), shepherd's pie (ground lamb with a potato crust), or Guinness and Beef Pie, which is one of McKenna's favorites.

What health issues does corned beef cause? ›

Since corned beef is loaded with sodium, those with or at-risk of heart disease, high blood pressure and stroke should only indulge in moderation. A low-sodium diet and healthy choices more often will be beneficial in the long-term.

Why do Irish Americans eat corned beef? ›

With more money for food, the Irish could afford meat for the first time. But instead of their beloved bacon, the Irish began eating beef. And the beef they could afford just happened to be corned beef, the thing their great-grandparents were famous for.

Do people in Ireland eat corned beef? ›

Corned beef and cabbage isn't actually the national dish of Ireland. You wouldn't eat it on St. Patrick's Day in Dublin, nor would you be likely to find it in Cork. It's typically only eaten around the holiday here in the U.S. So how did corned beef and cabbage become synonymous with the Irish?

What is the national dish of Ireland? ›

The National Dishes of Ireland

Irish Stew is a thick, hearty dish of mutton, potatoes, and onions and undisputedly the national dish of Ireland.

What is Irish bacon? ›

Unlike American bacon, Irish bacon is made from the back of the pig instead of the belly and is much leaner than streaky bacon. I used a presliced Irish bacon for this recipe but whole versions are available in British specialty shops. Most of the flavor in this dish comes from the bacon that you choose.

Why is it called corned beef when there is no corn? ›

Corned beef, or salt beef in some Commonwealth countries, is salt-cured brisket of beef. The term comes from the treatment of the meat with large-grained rock salt, also called "corns" of salt. Sometimes, sugar and spices are added to corned beef recipes. Corned beef is featured as an ingredient in many cuisines.

Do Irish people eat corned beef in Ireland? ›

Corned beef and cabbage isn't actually the national dish of Ireland. You wouldn't eat it on St. Patrick's Day in Dublin, nor would you be likely to find it in Cork. It's typically only eaten around the holiday here in the U.S. So how did corned beef and cabbage become synonymous with the Irish?

Is corned beef a traditional Irish dish? ›

Corned beef is not an Irish national dish, and the connection with Saint Patrick's Day specifically originates as part of Irish-American culture, and is often part of their celebrations in North America. Corned beef was used as a substitute for bacon by Irish immigrants in the late 19th century.

What is a traditional Irish dish? ›

Traditional dishes, such as Irish stew, coddle, the Irish breakfast, and potato bread have enjoyed a resurgence in popularity.

What is the typical Irish meal? ›

Think slow-cooked roasts, stews, delectable shellfish, grass-fed beef, sausage, potatoes, cabbage, homemade cheese and dense breads slathered with homemade butter.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Terence Hammes MD

Last Updated:

Views: 5807

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Terence Hammes MD

Birthday: 1992-04-11

Address: Suite 408 9446 Mercy Mews, West Roxie, CT 04904

Phone: +50312511349175

Job: Product Consulting Liaison

Hobby: Jogging, Motor sports, Nordic skating, Jigsaw puzzles, Bird watching, Nordic skating, Sculpting

Introduction: My name is Terence Hammes MD, I am a inexpensive, energetic, jolly, faithful, cheerful, proud, rich person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.